Shelter Island, NY
restaurants
Posted over 5 years ago
Commander Cody's Seafood
Epitome of a hidden gem. Best “greasy” seafood on the island. Everything is fresh. Fried chicken and fish and chips highly recommended. I do recommend take-out because the purpose of this place is gritty, real, down-home food. (Although there are tables to eat! And totally fine if you do!)
0
Shelter Island, NY
restaurants
Posted over 5 years ago
Salt
Right on the harbor, good food. Parking is ample, but recommend that you ride bikes so that you can hang out. Any sushi dish is good and I recommend the Poke bowl. Above all else, GREAT SETTING. Check out the Shipwreck bar for drinks afterwards.
0
Shelter Island Heights, NY
bar • restaurants
Posted almost 5 years ago
Isola
Fantastic higher end Italian food. Great staff who really care about the restaurant and the island. Outdoor seating on the porch is amazing on a beautiful night. The pizza is delicious!
0
Shelter Island, NY
bar
Posted almost 5 years ago
Shipwreck Bar
This bar is located next to Salt restaurant and is an awesome spot. It’s an old boat that has been remade into an outdoor bar with lots of bar and lawn games right on the harbor. I recommend the Whale Killer drink. Go before dinner in late afternoon or for the late evening scene.
0
